Today, was the Shikker Dovid’s all time favorite daf. Eruvin 13 has so much to it,.I encourage all to read it, daven over it. Sleep with it under your pillow. Drink over it.
The mishna in the previous page cites a discussion and controversy between Beit Shammi and Beit Hillel. The Gemara then goes off an tangents. However it winds up back to Beith Shammai and Hiellel. The Talmud gives the reason for our usual practice of following the opinion of Hillel. The reason is that usually in the Talmud, Hillel allows Shammai to speak first. He allows him to give his opinion first. Hillel quotes Shammai first and then gives his opinion. The Talmud tells us that from this humility, his opinions are raised. The Talmud tells us that Hashem raises the humble and lowers the haughty.
Second; The Talmud gives business advice. The Talmud cryptically states: If you push and hour, the hour pushes back. The Talmud explains, this is referring to our business efforts. We can push, strive, plot and plan, but if it is not the right time, we will see no brocha from our efforts. The Magid Shiur, dramatically and beautifully illustrated this by saying, sometimes, we must be patient and wait out a bad spell. Then restart with our efforts.
Lastly, the Talmud reverts back to Shammai and Hillel. It records their longest and greatest controversy. The Talmud explains that for two years they argued whether it was better to be born or not. The final decision was it was better not to be born.
The Shikker Dovid was trying to put all this together. It’s alot. It’s deep. But its all over the place.
What is the connection. The connection is the Tosfos that comments on the controversy . The Tosfos says, that if one acts righteously, it is better to be born.
That is the answer. Act righteously, humbly and modestly. That is the connection to all of life.
Beautiful! I think i once learned while on the one hand, the neshama wants to come down to earth to do mitzvos and raise its level in shomayim, it suffers while it is down here from all the tuma. we all have to strive to complete our tikkun in our lifetime by acting righteously and therefore not causing the neshama to have to come back down for more.
Keep it up Shikker Dovid!
Band be at the right place in time 🙂
*************************** Oliver B. Mitchell RobotGalaxy Command Center 22 East 17th Street, Bunker 1326 New York, NY 10003 Planet Earth T: (212) 242-0123 RobotGalaxy.com
ok. What does that mean?
David M. Ascher Attorney at Law 150 Broadway, suite 1600 New York, NY 10038 Tel: 212-964-1515 Fax: 212-240-0365
i’m shocked that the conclusion is better not to be born at all. aren’t we taught that hashem created this world in order for us to form a relationship with him?isn’t it better that we receive opportunities to worship hashem? even if evil befalls us, we are trained to believe that it was g-d’s plan, and it will eventually lead to good. so if there is suffering int his lifetime, isn’t it preferable than no existance at all?
Dear Shikker dovid Don’t forget to email me the Carlback song. Dada
On Thu, Mar 21, 2013 at 10:15 AM, ShikkerDovid