Shabbos 21: Hanukah without a Menora?

Today’s daf 21 is famous for it deals first with the type of oil for the hanuka menorah, then the process of lighting of the menorah, the famous debate between Hillel and Shamai of whether we start lighting the menorah with 8 candles (shammai) or 1 candle (Hillel) and work 8-1 (shammai) or 1-8 (Hillel).  Then the Talmud famously asks : What is Hanukaa? The Talmud tells us the story of the battle with the greeks and the jug of oil.

The Talmud then says “the year after, it was instituted as Yom Tov with Hallel and Praise.” At this point The Great Magid Shiur Saul Lubetsky asked a simple question. What is missing.? There is no mention of lighting the Menora- just Hallel and praise.  The class protested that the Talmud just spent nearly a page dealing with lighting.   Saul is right.The answer is very profound.  At the time Hanuka was instituted, the Temple stood and the Menorah in the Temple was lit.

It is hard to envision a Hanuka celebration or holiday without lighting a Menorah. The truth is that the holiday and lighting are synonomous to us. It is so deeply engraved in our consciousness and has seeped into popular culture that even Rugrats and Snoopy light Hanuka candles.

The SD would  like to weigh in.    We constantly have re-imagine and re-examine are service of gd  The question posed is really novel to the SD. How could we have a Hanuka without a Menora?  Nowadays when we sit in our homes due to the pandemic rather than go to shul, visit the sick or the hospitals, shun other people- all of which is so essential to our Jewish life and values we are forced to re-examine our avodas hashem.  We have to find a way to connect with Hashem without 0ur normal structures and systems.  A Hanuka without a Menora is a symbol for us that we must rethink in these days how we will serve Hashem

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Shabbos 21: Hanukah without a Menora?

  1. Joe Orlian says:

    Your divrei torah give me a closer connection to Hashem!

    I hope that you are managing ok under the circumstances. I am working from home, going in once a week to pick up mail and exchange files. How likely is it to get any new cases??
    Stay healthy and safe, and have a great Shabbos. Best to Sabrina and the kids.


    Law Offices of Joseph I. Orlian, PC

    New York City office:
    277 Broadway, Suite 408
    New York, NY 10007
    Phone: (212) 566-2266
    Fax: (212) 566-4780

    Westchester office:
    600 Mamaroneck Avenue
    Suite 400
    Harrison, NY 10528
    Phone: (914) 236-0536
    Fax: (212) 566-4780

    This communication, and any information or material transmitted with this communication, is intended only for the use of the intended recipients and it may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any review, retransmission, conversion to hard copy, copying, circulation, publication, dissemination, distribution, reproduction or other use of this communication, information or material is prohibited and may be illegal. If you received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by telephone or by return e-mail, and delete the communication, information and material from any computer, disk drive, diskette or other storage device or media. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s